Author: Daigensui
Disclaimer: This post is speculative. There is no guarantee this will be a tier 10 tank destroyer, it’s just a thought, not a “leak” in any way.
Hello everyone,
just some preliminary info on the possible tier 10 Japanese TD by Daigensui, if you are interested.
Ho-Ri Toku
An experimental project, never got past the mock-up stage.
Weight: 45 tons
Engine: 900hp
Gun: 300mm+ penetration experimental 105mm high-power gun (historical, existed – 16kg shell at 1000+ m/s, tungsten-chrome-steel alloy shells),
Armor: frontal armor (the sloped part) is 125mm at 70 degrees, the superstructure front is 250mm thick, sides are very thin (25-50mm)
Japanese tank destroyers and heavy tanks however won’t come anytime soon, possibly not even next year.
Looks a bit like the Jagdpanzer E-100 :O
more like jagdpanther 2 on steroids
jagpanther II + ferdi
My kind of tank.
It’d say, (3/2)*JgdPzV+JgdPzIV(H).
Looks like SU-76.
actually it really looks like giant su-85b with no open top
btw, the rof should be insane on this thing. So, basically, if it gets high-pen low-dmg insane dpm gun and that armor it should play like british TDs
Except for the fact that it has 20 HP/ton.
I’d be pleasantly surprised if the Japs get more than a med and a heavy branch.
Let’s see….. a full light branch, two medium branches, a heavy branch, a TD branch, and a SPG branch.
Plenty, of room.
Full light tank branch? all the way up to a tier 10? and wich are the other mediums?
wut? tier X light?
wait, we already have a bat chat
“Full light branch” means until tier 8 ofc. The other medium line would consist probably of paper late-war projects, the Japanese had something like the E-series.
Didn’t Serb say the top Japanese light tank is tier 4 because they could not find anything better?
more like the currently dont have enough info on higher tier candidates
Full ligt branch gives impression of up to tier 10, and didnt WG say that they might make tier 10 lights?
Anyway, small misunderstanding there.
They specifically said that they WOULDN’T make Tier 10 lights many times, and it looks like they’re sticking to it, which is truly a shame, as I would love to be able to keep a light tank crew all the way up to the BatChat. Maybe put the 13 105 with horrible bloom, aim time, somewhat poorer acceleration due to more weight, etc. to compensate for the same 105 a Tier lower as to replace the Lorr. so it can be a full to Tier 10 light tank line?
Well, it seems the Japanese line is going to get alot more love than the Chinese line. Still, to think that the Japanese would have a TD line and a heavy line… damn I really can not wait to play the Japanese.
dat angle *_*
The japanese and their names…
U-Mad?
Kawaii :3
Or whatever the word is. It looks really good on paper. Nice front armor, really good if you keep at least some distance, gun should have great DPM with a great RoF and lacking AlphaDMG, have good aim-time and excellent accuracy (possibly WT E-100 level or even better). The HP/t ratio is just awesome, could have great mobility and agility.
And that’s why I suspect that it if it ever appears, it will not be as good as it looks. Low alpha and shitty side/rear armor aren’t enough to make it balanced, so I would expect quite bad View range, terrain passability, gun elevation &depression, gun traverse angle. Still, could be quite enjoyable machine to play.
And it looks cute – me wants.
A majority of tanks have bad side armor and very shitty rear armor.
True, that’s why I said it can’t be viewed as a defect big enough.
I’m pretty sure if this will be implemented, this will be the new ROF king… (meet your match Tortoise) The 105mm will be having damage around 390+ or something if we follow WoT’s damage system… And for a tier 10 TD that damage is lackluster.. So it would have its ROF buffed to the extreme and it might even surpass Tortoise.
ROF = DPM… FTR y u no have edit..
And also, if I were to base it on the model.. That thing will have poor gun depression, the roof will limit it and it will also have small gun arc, the holes are too small.
Actually, it was -10 degrees depression and +/- 11 degrees traverse.
105mm is too weak in term of alpha dmg in tier X battle
I doth wonder however the mediums ever manage.
later tier 105s have something like 390 alpha and with 300mm+ pen (assuming that’s for the normal rounds) it’s not bad. the gun could be workable depending on the fire rate and accuracy. Depending on it’s mobility, camouflage, etc it could be a decent TD. We’ll just have to wait and see
Uh top tier 105mm guns have exactly 268mm pen, not sure where you got 300mm +
Maybe read the whole tanks specs posted ?
because it’s tier 10 TD, it alpha will abit bigger than the rest similar caliber gun. We have someTD gun ingame like this: obj 263 vs IS-7 (550 vs 490), JT vs Maus (560 vs 490). SO we can expect a bit more alpha in this gun, around 440~490 with decent RoF (7~7.5), so it Dpm is around 3300~3430
I don’t expect a high rate of fire. Was reading a report on a 120mm Japanese gun from 1945 and it complained about the breach design a lot and how it hampered ROF due to the gun being a hand loaded vs a semi-automatic design. However it also boasted of the guns HE shell design, fuzes and fragmentation.
http://sill-www.army.mil/firesbulletin/archives/1945/SEP_1945/SEP_1945_FULL_EDITION.pdf
PDF pg # 28.
Daigensui you might find some more reports buried in the volumes.
http://sill-www.army.mil/firesbulletin/archives
Personally, I rather stick to 10 cm guns, since the single tray autoloader for them were fully developed. We’re talking about more than 10 rounds per minute if it weren’t for the problem of game balance.
It will be interesting to see how WG balances things. Although if it were up to me everything would have historical ROF and Penn with damage, acc and health points being the overall balance factors.
>Was reading a report on a 120mm Japanese gun from 1945
This AA gun is Type 10 12 cm AA Gun. Very old AA Gun, 1920s design.
Ho-Ri 105mm Gun’s semi-automatic design based on “Type 3 12 cm AA Gun”.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Type_3_12_cm_AA_Gun
I know it was an old design. The report was from 1945.
Hmmmm, what was the gun they were choosing then?
SO what is the difference between Ho Ri, Ho Ri Kai and Ho Ri Toku?
The third word is missing in first name and the other two have it different. :derp:
The Ho-Ri I had more of a boxy hull and superstructure in the rear, like the German Ferdinand
Ho-Ri II has the superstructure moved to the middle of the hull like the JagdTiger
Ho-Ri Toku has the sloped front that we see in the pic on this article
I mean 300+mm penentration is totally retarded. Also 1000+ m/s is also kinda funny. This TD in terms if firepower seem a bit too modern compared to the current ones.
Good. Cause in terms of Armor and probably mobility its crap.
What is good? Also since when is armor strung in wota tier 10?
Well most tanks didn’t even fire tungsten rounds all the time. It is likely the tungsten-chrome-steel alloy shells will be premium shells. Just like the French APC shells for the 47mm on the Char B1 are premium rounds when in fact they were the stock round for the gun.
Don’t worry so much. There is a lot of powder behind that shell. Plus if its APCBC then the shell speed makes even more sense. I don’t see anything too modern here at all. Suspension is likely something similar to Volute Spring Suspension.
I think this tank will be fine at tier 9-10. You might just have to learn to play it differently. Instead of standing in front of a guy and taking shots all day long.
tungsten-chrome-steel alloy shell
sounds like a premium round?
Most likely.
http://ja.wikipedia.org/wiki/%E8%A9%A6%E8%A3%BD%E4%BA%94%E5%BC%8F%E7%A0%B2%E6%88%A6%E8%BB%8A
wiki page(japanese)
According to that wiki the rate of fire is one round per second…
No, it took one second for the recoil to finish so the gun is ready for loading.
Which means adding in the time to load the shell and fire the gun makes 10 rpm all the more correct.Although it depends on how coordinated the crew is to get a 10 rpm firing speed. Ergonomics and all that crap. =)
Thinking a superstructure roomer than Ferdinand or Jagdtiger. That’s how good the ergonomics was especially in light of the smaller crew.
Exactly. =)
A Tier 10 JgPanther2 equivalent sounds like my cup of tea. Looking cool is just a bonus.
With about 9 RPM (3510 DPM), 2,1 seconds of aiming time and 70 or more side armour so it doesn’t get overmatched by most mediums and heavys guns when you angle it after every shoot (because of the casemate flat armour). That and good traverse would make an awesome medium-td (just like the JP II and the StuG III)
One year ago, SerB said “Ho-Ri I and Ho-Ri II TD will be coming Tier 7-8″.
And Ho-Ri Toku is neither of those.
“Full SPG and Full TD branch” is necessary? I don’t think so.
And things change.
looks ugly.
id rather have more glorious motherland tanks
Does the tungsten chrome steel alloy act like APCR or did they have a newer shell like HESH/HEAT?
Basic APHE.
Not necessarily. tungsten-steel alloy was used in a wide variety of ammo like apcbc or apcr. It was actually NOT very good to be used on aphe munition since it tended to break easily which resulted in complete impact fuse failure or premature “outside armor” detonation.
World of Prototypes